Lake Pend Oreille Waterkeeper
  • Our Work
    • Priority Issues >
      • BNSF Bridge Expansion
      • Transport of Hazardous Materials by Rail
      • Stormwater >
        • Stormwater Monitoring Program
      • Wastewater
      • Invasive Species and Herbicides
      • Water Resources
      • PacWest Silicon Smelter >
        • PacWest Silicon Smelter - Scoping Comments
    • Programs and Campaigns >
      • Water Quality Monitoring Program
      • WQMP Data and Resource Hub >
        • Lake Pend Oreille WQM Interactive Map
        • WQM Parameters
    • Outreach and Education
  • Kid's Corner
    • Science For Schools
    • Watershed Discovery Camp
  • Get Involved
    • Donate
    • Membership
    • Sentinels Club
    • Volunteer
    • Report Pollution
  • Recent News
  • Events
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Stay Informed

Hearing Nears on LPOW Petition

1/29/2013

 
By KEITH KINNAIRD News editor

SANDPOINT — Oral arguments on Lake Pend Oreille Waterkeeper’s effort to compel the state to embrace the use of biological controls in combating Eurasian milfoil are set for Wednesday in Lewiston.

Jeff Brudie, a 2nd District judge with chambers in Nez Perce County, is hearing the case.

Lake Pend Oreille Waterkeeper calls the proceeding another critical step in the water quality watchdog group’s journey to add biological controls to the Idaho State Department of Agriculture’s arsenal of methods for controlling the aquatic noxious weed.

Waterkeeper filed a petition for judicial review last year, after the ISDA declined to revise its rules to allow for the use of weevils to devour milfoil infestations in the lake.

Groups in Bonner County have advocated the use of weevils for the last several years as an alternative to herbicides. Partners for Milfoil Control subsequently raised $150,000 to conduct a research to demonstrate the insects’ efficacy in beating back milfoil.

But ISDA blocked the project because it involved placing pieces of weevil-laden  Eurasian milfoil back into the water, which the state holds is expressly forbidden under Idaho’s noxious weed law.

Waterkeeper subsequently tried to have the state amend the noxious weed law to include the use of biological controls, but the group was rebuffed.

The group argues the agency misinterpreted the plain language of the state’s noxious weed law and disregarded its own goals regarding the use of biological controls. ISDA countered that it lacked permitting authority and harbored concerns about the use of weevils.

“The fact that the ISDA continues to focus their rationale for rejection of one type of biological control is beyond frustrating. We went to great lengths to ensure that our initial Petition was all encompassing with respect to various forms of biological control, including parasites and pathogens,” Shannon Williamson, executive director of LPOW, said in a statement.

ISDA has further argued that LPOW’s substantial rights had not been prejudiced by its decision. LPOW disagrees.

“LPOW’s constituents are prejudiced by ISDA because its decision to continue using herbicides to control noxious weeds directly relates to the purpose of LPOW as an organization, which seeks to defend the substantial and fundamental rights of its constituents to clean water,” Williamson said in an affidavit.

Counsel for ISDA do not dispute that biological controls have a role in noxious weed controls, but they have to be utilized under the right circumstances.

“It simply cannot risk further infestations by allowing the movement and/or introduction of viable noxious weeds into the very environment from which Idaho has sought to eradicate them, whether for research or for other purposes,” deputy attorneys general Angela Kaufmann and Sean Costello said in court documents.

Williamson said the group will lobby state lawmakers to bring changes to the noxious weed law if it does not prevail in court.

“This has been a long process and valuable learning experience. We don’t take the litigation lightly and only engage in this process when all other options have been exhausted,” said Williamson said in the LPOW’s statement.


Comments are closed.
    Lake Pend Oreille Waterkeeper is a non-profit organization located in Sandpoint, Idaho.  

    Mission
    Our mission is to protect water quality in the Clark Fork/Pend Oreille Watershed so our magnificent waterways remain drinkable, fishable and swimmable for future generations. 

    ​Learn more

    Categories

    All
    Best Management Practices
    Citizen Science
    Coal
    Community Donations
    Herbicides
    Lessons Learned
    Lpo Fishery
    Oil By Rail
    Recreational Boating
    Stormwater
    Volunteering
    Waterkeeper Alliance Magazine
    Watermilfoil
    Water Quality Monitoring Program
    Water Resource Management

    RSS Feed

About

​Our Mission
Our Work
Priority Issues

Water Quality Monitoring Program
News



Get Involved

​Donate
Volunteer
Become a Member
Become a Citizen Scientist
Events
Report Pollution
Contact Us

334 N. First
Suite 209
Sandpoint, ID 83864
(208) 597-7188
Picture
Lake Pend Oreille Waterkeeper is a proud member of the WATERKEEPER® Alliance, which is a global movement of on-the-water advocates that protect their local waterways.  Founded by environmental attorney Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. as a culmination of decades of citizen-based enforcement, the WATERKEEPER® Alliance is a unifying body for nearly 300 local Waterkeeper organizations worldwide.  Waterkeepers combine firsthand knowledge of their waterbodies with an unwavering commitment to the rights of their communities and to the rule of law. Waterkeepers defend their communities against anyone who threatens our fundamental right to clean water.
© 2019 Lake Pend Oreille Waterkeeper
Website by NewPickle Pro CMS